Review: 1/48 Eduard P-38J Lightning Limited Edition

The Lockheed P-38 Lightning is a rare thing in the modeling world – an absolutely iconic design that nobody has really managed to nail…yet. The three principal efforts – those of Monogram (these days repopped by Revell), Academy and Hasegawa – are all compromised in their own ways. The Monogram was absolutely cutting edge when it was released long ago, but it’s showing its age, with non-existent gear bays, gimmicky features that interfere with fit, some missed details like the upkink in the underside wingtips, and shallow detail in the cockpit. The Academy improves upon the Monogram in terms of shape and detail, but not to a great degree, and is plagued by boom alignment issues, a fickle canopy, and other build-up headaches. Likewise, the Hasegawa has a reputation as a pain of a build. The fact that the old Monogram is still a totally viable option – even with price taken out of the equation – speaks volumes.

In my opinion, it’s only a matter of time before someone unleashes a new 1/48 Lightning upon the modeling world and blows these three kits out of the water. The only question that remains: who will take the plunge?

While we wait, Eduard has given us a promising new entry in the form of a limited release P-38J. The plastic is Academy, but it’s what Eduard brings to the table that makes this package special – hefty amounts of resin, photo etch, canopy masks and one rather extensive decal sheet.

Do Eduard’s power-ups make this one worth your time? Let’s find out…


3 Comments Add yours

  1. says:

    Doogs,so glad you brought up the topic of the P-38 [ my favorite WWII Plane ] enigma. I’d think it’d be a shoe-in for update,alas not so. I’ve enjoyed & learned much from your blog, in general.Yet,being an armor guy, I miss your builds in that arena.Are you gonna come back to armor anytime soon ? Thanks & keep posting, Keith R.

    1. Doogs says:

      Hey Keith – armor’s not out of the picture, I’ve just been more taken with aircraft of late. And for the next few months that won’t change much as I’ve got two involved builds that need to happen before the holidays. After that, who knows? I’ve had a hankering to do some Soviet armor, of all things, so we’ll see what comes next. Perhaps a Stalin?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.